Articles
BACK TO ARTICLES
CRIA Scoring System
by Linda Berry Walker,
Dean P. Neely, VMD, PhD, WoodsEdge Wools Veterinarian, and
Ann M. Showan, MD
All breeders eagerly anticipate the birth of each alpaca cria. It is
a moment in which many breeders anxiously hold their breath.
Even those experienced at birthing clench their jaws in realization
that it's all "on the line" with each new birth. Fortunately, alpacas
have been selected for 5,000 years on the basis of unassisted birthing
and will birth easily and unassisted the vast majority of times.
However, the statistics of low loss nationally can change dramatically
when you have a small herd. When you're expecting only two crias in a
year and one dies, that's a 50% loss! Even breeders with large herds,
who are more insulated from a high statistical loss due to greater numbers,
have a strong financial incentive to save every baby. Without a doubt,
most of us have an even stronger emotional motivation to ensure each
live birth is a successful birth! There are educational articles, video
tapes, lectures and seminars available to better prepare an alpaca
owner for cria births. Although these are excellent aids, when it's
you and the newborn alone in your barn, you need a simple method to
objectively assess the well-being of your newborn.
The cria is not merely a miniature version of the adult alpaca; in
many ways it closely resembles neonates of other species. "All
mammalian neonates undergo a rapid change from an aquatic environment
supplying total respiratory, metabolic, nutritional and thermal support,
to an environmental situation where survival depends upon immediate
transition to air breathing ... " [Drummond, W.H.: Proceedings from
symposium, The Application of Intensive Care Therapies and Parenteral
Nutrition in Large Animal Medicine. August 1986]. Thus the conscientious
breeder must learn how to evaluate the newborn, recognize problems, and
know what steps can be taken on the farm within those first critical
minutes of life to maximize survival until professional assistance
arrives.
In all neonates, the two most vital systems for immediate survival are
the respiratory and circulatory systems. Should either of these systems
fail to adjust to the new external environment within minutes after
birth, the newborn may develop signs associated with inadequate oxygen
delivery to the vital organs of the body (anoxia signs). Should the
lungs fail to inflate properly due to prematurity or obstruction,
there will be inadequate oxygen available to the blood for circulation.
Should the heart be unable to efficiently pump blood throughout the body,
or if there is a substantial loss of the cria's blood, there will be
inadequate red blood cells to transport oxygen to the vital organs.
Vital organs such as the brain (central nervous system), kidneys (renal
system) and liver (hepatic system) would suffer from this oxygen
deprivation, and life-threatening conditions would occur if immediate
supportive measures are not initiated.
Anoxia to the central nervous system can cause the condition of
depressed behavioral attitude with such terms, coined in other species,
as "dummies," "wanderers," and neonatal maladjustment syndrome. Anoxia
to the cerebrum of the brain can cause edema and hemorrhage. Signs
associated with this may not appear until one to 24 hours after birth.
Common observations are failure to nurse; wandering into walls (which
can be associated with temporary blindness); irregular sucking or
chewing movements; the inability to stand or right the body into sternal
positioning; exaggerated, uncoordinated leg movements and even
convulsions.
Anoxia to the kidneys or liver can be associated with the death of vital
organ cells thereby preventing the removal of waste products from the
blood. Unpurified blood would have increased amounts of toxins and
chemicals, such as urea and acid products, which would add to the stress
of the already compromised newborn.
Thus, it is of prime importance that the newborn's initial respiratory
and circulatory efforts be stimulated to ensure that life-sustaining
oxygen enters the lungs and is carried by the blood to cells throughout
the body. The simple but important act of drying the cria may be all
that is needed to stimulate respiratory reflexes and normal
cardiovascular functioning. In addition, oxygen and energy stores will
be conserved by the prevention of heat loss through evaporation.
Working with human babies in the early 1950s, Dr. Virginia Apgar
recognized the need for a simple, standardized score which could clearly
identify depressed infants requiring resuscitation or supplemental
oxygen. Today, a universally accepted scoring system carries her
name and is known as the APGAR score. [Apgar, V.: Proposal for a new
method of evaluation of the newborn infant. Current Researches in
Anesthesia and Analgesia 1953; 32:260] The score focuses on five vital
signs -- heart rate, respiratory effort, muscle tone, reflex irritability
and color. Each criterion is evaluated and given a numeric value of
0, 1 or 2 which is recorded at one minute and five minutes after birth.
Thus, infants needing active resuscitation or supplemental oxygen are
quickly and clearly identified so that they may receive optimal
observation and therapy.
The Equine Neonatology Study Group from the University of Florida
College of Veterinary Medicine, a multidisciplinary team, formulated
a similar scoring system for foals in the early 1980s. Perhaps it was in
part the recognized usefulness of APGAR scoring in humans, and the
resultant reduced mortality rate, that precipitated the approach.
Collectively, we began to discuss an alpaca/llama [lama] scoring
system for quick and objective evaluation of newborn crias. Utilizing
the original human APGAR system as well as the foal scoring system,
we developed the CRIA SCORING SYSTEM.
C -- CARDIAC RATE
Compared to humans and foals, there is a paucity of research data on
lama neonates. We arrived at scoring values intuitively, based on
currently available information for lama neonates and our collective
experiences. With continued accumulation of data, parameters
distinguishing a score of 1 from a score of 2 may change. To date we
have observed heart rates in alpaca neonates as high as 130 to 140,
and this can be highly variable in association with the physical
ability of the newborn cria. (Remember, neonatal heart rates will be
considerably higher than adult rates.) It is the lower levels (less than
60 to 80 BPM) which can be problematic and are of concern.
Hear rate is determined by cardiac auscultation, using a stethoscope or
by palpation. Without a stethoscope, one can hold fingers gently on
either side of the chest, between the front legs, to feel the heartbeat.
The axillary artery, located behind the front leg in the "armpit" may
also be palpated. Using your index finger you can feel the pulsation
and count the number of beats in a 15-second time period. Multiply
that number of beats times four to calculate the heartbeats per minute (BPM).
R -- RESPIRATORY EFFORT
In humans, the initial respiratory rate is considered less important
than the actual quality of the respiratory effort. In foals, both the
nature of respiration, as well as the measured respiratory rate are
used to determine the score in this category. In newborn crias we have
elected not to incorporate the respiratory rate in the scoring system due
to variability associated with the cria's physical activity. Instead,
we focused on the nature of the respiratory efforts being made by the
cria.
The neonate with no spontaneous breathing or respiratory effort scores 0.
The cria whose respirations are labored, noisy or irregular, or who is
gasping for breath with mouth open and nostrils flaring, scores 1; where
the cria whose score is 2 shows a steady respiratory pattern.
I -- IRRITANT RESPONSE
Response to stimuli is easily assessed by gently inserting a piece of
straw or stiff grass into the cria's nostril. No response to persistent
intranasal tickling with the straw scores 0. The cria who grimaces,
exhibiting only mild rejection scores 1. The cria who sneezes or coughs
and tries to pull away or shake his head attempting to get rid of the
irritant scores 2.
A -- ACTIVITY/MUSCLE TONE
Veterinarians are familiar with assessing muscle tone and could easily
score on the basis of limp = 0, some tone = 1, and good tone = 2.
Breeders may find activity levels as an aid in scoring muscle tone.
In humans, babies with active movement or flexion or their arms and
legs are rated a 2, whereas a completely flaccid infant receives a score
of 0 in this category. A score of 1 denotes activity somewhere in
between. A cria actively kicking and trying to achieve an upright
position scores a 2, whereas the cria whose movement efforts are
limited to the neck and head scores 1. A cria with minimal or no
movement scores 0. We believe that evaluating erect ears at one and
ten minutes after birth may not be a reliable indicator of muscle tone.
EVALUATION OF THE CRIA SCORE
In humans, the heart rate and respiratory effort are the most important
factors in identifying a distressed newborn, with color of least value.
In foals, mucous membrane coloration as an evaluation of oxygenation
is not reliable. Since many cria have darkly pigmented mucosal surfaces,
adequate evaluation of color and capillary refill cannot always be
ascertained.
As in foals, the CRIA score is based on a total of four criteria
assessed with a total of eight points. We discussed the inclusion of
other appearance criteria, but for simplicity elected to stick to four
criteria and a total of eight points. However, it may be worth noting
an extra two points could be used for scoring the condition of the
owner -- if in control, score 2, if shaking and hyperventilating, score 1;
and if fainted, score 0.
Like the APGAR score, we have developed an objective, easily applied
system of evaluating each newborn cria to 1) assess its immediate
condition, 2) determine the amount of support required to provide
critical life functions, and 3) evaluate the urgency in which a
veterinarian is needed. Our crias are observed at one and ten minutes
after parturition using the following total scores:
0-3 |
Critical |
Notify veterinarian of emergency |
4-6 |
Marginal |
Notify veterinarian if second score is not improving |
7-8 |
Good |
Normal supportive care |
IMMEDIATE SUPPORTIVE ACTIONS
As soon as delivery is completed, make sure nothing is obstructing the
airway passages of the nostrils or mouth. Immediately begin brisk
rubbing along the cria's back and sides. Using your flattened palm,
with or without a handful of straw or a dry towel, rub vigorously
to stimulate the cria, as well as dry it off. Provide as much warmth
as you can in these initial minutes following birth, but your priorities
should be assessment of the cria's respiratory efforts and cardiac
function.
We have not observed the need to force fluid from the cria's lungs by
inverting the cria so that the head and neck are down, or the aggressive
maneuver of "centrifuging" the baby.
With cold weather births, keep in mind that the cria has been expelled
from a 100-degree Fahrenheit "oven" into a frigid environment with
temperatures plummeting 60 to 100 degrees! (Birthing in below 0-degree
Fahrenheit temperatures is not advised.) Preventing hypothermia is
essential. In a field birth situation use your body as a windbreak.
Once breathing is established, transport the cria to a sheltered area.
The immediate cold weather concerns are protecting the cria from drafts
and precipitation, and providing warmth in the form of deep straw
bedding, dry towels, blankets or even your coat.
OXYGEN THERAPY
Should rubbing stimuli not illicit the expected normal breathing
pattern, then it is paramount to provide some supportive oxygen
therapy. For many owners with only a few alpacas, oxygen sources may
not be available, or always needed, and the administration of artificial
respiration may be all that is required.
To apply artificial respiration, the "criation attendant" can place his
or her mouth over the cria's nose and mouth, gently blowing air into the
newborn's lungs to provide expansion of the chest and inflation of the
lungs with air. Such air will not be extremely high in oxygen, but it
will allow for "opening up" the airways and air sacks (alveoli) of the
lungs as well as stimulating the cria's respiratory reflexes. We
suggest providing 10 to 12 breaths per minute; then stop and observe
the cria's respiratory efforts for a minute to see if any additional
assistance is required.
Preferably, 100% oxygen should be available for administration when
large numbers of crias are expected, or where a dam has a history or
expectation of a problem delivery. Oxygen systems can be arranged
through your veterinarian and supplied by local medical gas supply
businesses or pharmacies. An oxygen regulator will be required to
administer a low flow rate. Presently for crias weighing 12 to 18
pounds (5.5 to 8.0 kg.) we are utilizing a flow rate of five liters
per minute of oxygen, administered by face mask or nasal tubing.
We administer oxygen for two to five minutes to those with a CRIA
score of less than 7, then repeat the CRIA scoring after a five-minute
rest period. We emphasize, do not provide 100% oxygen for prolonged
periods for fear of causing oxygen toxicity. With oxygen toxicity,
the newborn would lack the normal carbon dioxide response required to
regulate its own respiratory efforts. It is recommended that your
veterinarian evaluate all crias which required initial oxygen therapy
assistance.
Based on research in other neonates, the significance of prompt evaluation
and treatment of oxygen deprivation will be of major importance to
compromised neonates. Evaluation and treatment should not disturb the
natural bonding of dam and cria.
In conclusion, this simple scoring system provides breeders with an
immediate objective method to identify distressed newborns. It is a
useful general prognostic tool for veterinarians in assessing the vital
functions necessary to sustain life. However, even Dr. Apgar herself
cautioned that the score is no substitute for a careful physical
examination and close observation over the first hours of life. Her
caution is well-heeded by responsible breeders who routinely observe
their newborns for overall behavior, alertness and vigorous nursing in
conjunction with a professional evaluation within the first 24 hours
of life. All this can be done with minimal obtrusion into the natural
processes, and still allow the breeder the peace of mind that comes
from knowing the status of each newborn.
Figure 1. Human Apgar score is based on five signs, each scored 0, 1 or 2.
|
A |
P |
G |
A |
R |
|
Appearance |
Pulse |
Grimace |
Activity |
Respiration |
SCORE |
Color |
Heart Rate |
Reflex Irritability |
Muscle Tone |
Respiratory Effort |
0 |
Blue, Pale |
Absent |
No Response |
Limp |
Absent |
1 |
Body pink, Extremities blue |
Below 100 |
Grimace |
Some flexion of extremities |
Slow, irregular |
2 |
Completely pink |
Over 100 |
Cough, sneeze |
Active motion |
Good, crying |
Figure 2. CRIA SCORING SYSTEM for neonates within 1 and 10 minutes of birth.
|
C |
R |
I |
A |
SCORE |
Cardiac Rate |
Respiratory Effort |
Irritant Response |
Activity/Muscle Tone |
0 |
Undetectable |
Undetectable |
Unresponsive |
Limp/Laterally recumbent |
1 |
Less than 80 BPM |
Irregular, noisy. Mouth open, Flaring nostrils |
Grimace with mild rejection |
Some tone. Laterally recumbent with effort to achieve upright position |
2 |
Over 80 BPM |
Steady, Non-labored |
Sneeze/Cough, Pulling away from irritant |
Good tone, Sternal or actively trying to achieve upright position |
This landmark piece is copyrighted at the Library of Congress and is now being taught at veterinary schools across the country.
Copyright © 1992, Walker, Neely and Showan. All rights reserved.
|